Moving Between Provinces in Canada | Relocation Guide – Part 3
Should you rent first or buy a home before moving to another Canadian city?
There is no single answer. Renting provides flexibility and time to explore a new city, while buying before relocating may offer greater stability for families who are financially prepared and confident about where they want to live.
Having relocated from PEI to Vancouver and eventually Calgary, I've personally chosen to purchase a home before each move. I researched the cities and neighbourhoods carefully because I wanted to minimize disruptions to my children's schooling and daily routines.
But as a Calgary REALTOR® and Licensed Property Manager, I've also worked with families whose circumstances made renting first the more practical option.
Here are three common situations worth considering.
1. When Does Renting First Make Sense?
Renting can be a good option when you're unfamiliar with the city, still looking for employment, or uncertain about your long-term plans.
Living in a rental for several months gives you an opportunity to understand neighbourhoods, commuting times, schools, amenities, and everyday living costs before committing to a property purchase.
It can also reduce the pressure of buying quickly in an unfamiliar market.
However, renting isn't without costs. You may need to move twice, pay for temporary storage, or arrange another school transition for your children.
Renting first is most valuable when the flexibility and information it provides outweigh those additional costs.
2. When Could Buying Before Relocating Be the Better Choice?
Buying before moving may make sense if you have stable employment, sufficient savings, a clear understanding of your preferred neighbourhood, and plans to remain in the city for several years.
One relocating family I worked with wanted a detached home rather than another townhouse. Their children were active, and they hoped to avoid further neighbour complaints and repeated school changes.
For them, settling directly into a suitable long-term home was an important priority.
Still, buying requires more than having enough for a down payment.
Before committing, consider:
Mortgage qualification, particularly if you're changing employers or starting a new job.
Closing costs, property taxes, home insurance, maintenance, and potential repairs.
Your emergency savings after completing the purchase.
Whether the neighbourhood genuinely suits your family's daily life.
A mortgage pre-approval can help establish a budget, but it does not guarantee final financing approval. Employment changes and property-specific requirements should be discussed with your lender before making a purchase commitment.
3. What If You Need to Relocate Quickly?
Sometimes a new job requires someone to start within a few weeks, leaving little time to organize a permanent move.
For example, a relocating client received a job offer with a start date the following month. His plan was to move first, rent temporarily, settle into his new position, and bring his family later.
In this situation, short-term accommodation can provide valuable flexibility.
It may cost more per month, but it allows time to research housing and neighbourhoods without rushing the entire family into a major decision.
Before booking, check the accommodation's terms, availability, and any applicable local requirements.
4. Renting vs. Buying: What Should You Compare Financially?
One common mistake is comparing monthly rent with the mortgage payment alone.
The actual cost of owning a home includes several additional expenses.
Illustrative example — not a current Calgary market quote
Suppose a suitable rental costs $2,400 per month.
Now suppose a home purchase involves a $3,000 monthly mortgage payment, $300 in property taxes, $200 in insurance, and $250 set aside for maintenance.
The homeowner's estimated monthly cash outflow would be $3,750, compared with $2,400 in rent—a difference of $1,350.
However, this is not a complete rent-versus-buy investment comparison. Part of a mortgage payment reduces the loan principal, while purchasing also involves upfront costs, opportunity costs, potential changes in property value, and selling expenses.
The example simply demonstrates why comparing rent with the mortgage payment alone can be misleading.
5. Five Questions to Ask Before Deciding
Is my employment and household income sufficiently stable?
Do I understand the neighbourhoods, schools, and commuting patterns?
How long do I realistically expect to stay in this city?
Can I afford the full cost of ownership while maintaining emergency savings?
Would moving directly into a permanent home benefit my family more than the flexibility of renting?
The answers will be different for every household.
Clara's Perspective
I don't believe every family should rent for six months before buying. Nor do I believe purchasing immediately is always the best financial decision.
For my own family, buying before relocating helped provide continuity for my children. But that decision came after considerable research and financial planning.
Buying before relocating isn't necessarily the risky part. Buying without understanding the city, the neighbourhood, or your financial position is.
A beautiful home at an attractive price may still be the wrong choice if it creates a difficult commute, doesn't suit your children's schooling, or limits your family's financial flexibility.
The goal should never be to buy as quickly as possible. It should be to make a housing decision that supports the life you're building in your new city.
Next in the Series
Part 4: Moving Between Provinces in Canada — Costs, Documents and a Practical Moving Checklist
Helpful Resources
Disclaimer: This article provides general educational information based on personal and professional experience. Financial examples are illustrative. Mortgage eligibility, housing costs, tenancy requirements, and market conditions vary. Consult qualified professionals before making financial or legal decisions.
Comments:
Post Your Comment: